Monday, July 28, 2003

Young Republicans

I'm glad there's no more racism.

Ferruggia was sitting in the Capitol Hilton's lobby bar shortly after Rove's speech. There were three others with her -- another blond 19-year-old Georgetown student, Chris Sibeni, chairman of Hofstra College Republicans, and Jeffrey Chen, a recent Johns Hopkins graduate. Sibeni and Chen puffed on Fuente cigars.

...

Sibeni, who had spiky hair, glasses and a long face, is high-strung and given to rash pronouncements. He denounced assassinated civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. for "dividing the country" and trying to help African-Americans "advance over the white society," and defended American support of the brutal Augusto Pinochet regime in Chile. Chen, who went to high school with Sibeni in Great Neck, Long Island, is easy-going and quick to concede Republican mistakes, mocking his friend's more outré arguments.

While Sibeni declared that Bill Clinton had been more dangerous to America than Osama bin Laden, Chen defended the ex-president's economic program. Without him," Chen argued, "we would not have had globalization. He took a Republican idea, used it as a Democratic idea, and used it to become the most popular president of all time."

Chen seemed so mild and centrist that at one point I called him a closet Democrat. Taken aback, he replied: "How am I a closet Democrat? I'm racist, I love guns and I hate welfare."



And people mock the loony left.

Sunday, July 27, 2003

Thug watch

But the old-fashioned kind. Jill Barton of the AP writes:

Belle Glade, Fla. (AP) Not long after the family of Feraris ''Ray'' Golden found his dead body dangling from a tree outside his grandmother's home, ugly suspicions began to surface.

Let's hope lynching isn't making a comeback...




Kneepad alert

Judith Miller.

9/11 report whitewash summed up

In our own Inky, Auth.

(Not from an alternative weekly, but from the mainstream Philadelphia Inquirer. Interesting....)

Latest victims of Bush bait and switch tactics: Veterans

Steven Thomma of Knight-Ridder writes:

President Bush and his Republican Party are facing a political backlash from an unlikely group - retired veterans.

Normally Republican, many retired veterans are mad that Bush and the Republican-controlled Congress are blocking remedies to two problems with health and pension benefits. They say they feel particularly betrayed by Bush, who appealed to them in his 2000 campaign, and who vowed on the eve of his inauguration that "promises made to our veterans will be promises kept."

"He pats us on the back with his speeches and stabs us in the back with his actions," said Charles A. Carter of Shawnee, Okla., a retired Navy senior chief petty officer. "I will vote non-Republican in a heart beat if it continues as is."

Hell, Bush is privatizing the military anyhow. He must be figuring, Who needs these guys?

Tell me again why the Republicans are so good at supporting the troops?

Tim Russert asks a real question!

From the MTP transcript:

MR. RUSSERT: Let me show you something that you wrote in your report on this very subject: “The White House determined, and the DCI and CIA agreed, that the Joint Inquiry could have no access to the [President’s Daily Briefing].”

This was the briefing President Bush was given in August of 2001.

“Ultimately, this bar was extended to the point where CIA personnel were not allowed to be interviewed regarding the simple process by which the PDB is prepared. Although the inquiry was inadvertently given access to fragments of some PDB items early on, this decision limited the inquiry’s ability to determine systematically what Presidents Clinton and Bush, and their senior advisers, were being told by the intelligence community agencies, and when, regarding the nature of the threat to the United States from Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda.”

And the very day I read that in the report, I read this in The Washington Post: “Cheney laid out a detailed rationale for the war Bush launched on March 20, quoting at length from declassified sections of a National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) on Iraq issued in October. White House officials have cited the NIE as the basis for prewar pre-war speeches about Iraq. ... As part of an effort to rebut criticism that it had exaggerated the threat, the White House last Friday released eight pages of excerpts from the intelligence report,” which had been classified.

Senator Graham, why would we declassify the National Intelligence Report to buttress arguments about the war in Iraq but keep classified some information that could help us find out what our leaders knew was coming down before September 11?

Right straight down the middle!

SEN. GRAHAM: Well, I think one of the fundamental reasons for that is to avoid accountability.

And Senator Graham hits it out of the park!

How can we say there's no smoking gun if we can't look in every room of the house? What did the White House know and when did they know it? The 9/11 report leaves that part out.

Plenty of other good stuff in the MTP transcript, BTW. Have at it!

Iraq and terror as urban legend

Reuters via CNN here:

''I think as long as we're present here in Iraq, we will always have the threat of Islamic fundamentalists and terrorists coming to try to kill American and coalition soldiers, and that is something that we will have to contend with,'' [General Richard] Sanchez said.

''The key that we must not lose sight of is that we must win this battle here in Iraq. Otherwise America will find itself taking on these terrorists at home.''

Hello? America has already "taken on" these terrorists at home—that's what 9/11 was all about. And as the recently released 9/11 report shows, Iraq had nothing at all to do with that.

So what's with the "otherwise"?

And why did we go to war in Iraq again?

Troll prophylactic: Saddam is a "bad guy."

Winning hearts and minds

Guess my question (back) on Rules of Engagement for Saddam is partially answered. Way down in this CNN story we read:

But a raid in Baghdad's upscale Mansour district turned tragic, according to witnesses and an Iraqi police officer who said he'd been briefed by U.S. military officials. There, witnesses described U.S. commandos dressed in black cordoning off the area around a house and then opening fire on several vehicles.

The Iraqi police officer told CNN that the civilians, apparently unaware the military had closed the area, began driving. Three civilians were killed, he said, and four others wounded.

He said U.S. military officials told him the operation targeted Saddam.

Coalition military spokesman Capt. Jeff Fitzgibbons told CNN that the operation was conducted by Task Force 20, which is made up of special operations forces from the various branches of the armed services. But he would neither confirm nor deny the operation's target or the reports of civilian casualties.

(thanks to alert reader Jackson L. Haveck)

Then And Now

Have you wondered what would have been the reaction of the media and the Republicans if it had been President Gore in the oval office, or Air Force One on 9/11. *

Wonder no longer. Read this material from "former CIA officials," posted at Free Republic on 9/12, and the comments thread that follows it and you'll have a pretty good idea.

Most interesting, and in some respects amusing, is how wrong some of the usual assumptions have proved to be.

The way you PREVENT things like this is just that: Prevention. You find out about these things and you defuse the situation. You knock on doors in the early hours of the morning and herd half-awake, half-clothed would-be suicide Jihad-ers into waiting police vans.

This is how we have always prevented the majority of these tragedies.

(edit)

This time NO ONE KNEW!!! NO ONE HAD A CLUE!!!!

That's why we can say with confidence that our intelligence capability has suffered so drastically under Clinton

There's a lot of scary stuff, too, and most of all, repetition of charges disproved again and again, but never acknowledged as such by the mainstream media.

I post this unpleasantness now, because Democrats and those of us who need them to deprive Bush of another four damaging years are going to have to deal with some of the assumptions here, that will be thrown at all Democrats as easily as they were thrown at the Clintons.

*(I'm leaving aside the increasingly plausible possibility that under President Gore the 9/11 plot might have been uncovered before it could take place, or more easily foiled on the day itself; that's for another post)

**Under the "knowledge is power" rubric, always informative reader, Sara, informs us that an excellent book on the Clinton administration's actual engagement with the issue of terrorism is Daniel Benjamin and Steven Simon's "The Age of Sacred Terror"

Those 28 censored Saudi pages inthe 9/11 report

William C. Mann of the AP writes:

The Bush administration should make public the facts about Saudi Arabia's complicity with terrorists rather than worry about offending the kingdom, lawmakers said Sunday.

One senator said 95 percent of the classified pages of a congressional report released last week into the work of intelligence agencies before the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, was kept secret only to keep from embarrassing a foreign government.

''I went back and read every one of those pages, thoroughly. ... My judgment is 95 percent of that information could be declassified, become uncensored so the American people would know,'' said Shelby, R-Ala.

The 28 Saudi pages look like a tar baby to me—"Please don't force us to expose the 28 pages on the Saudis!"

Meaning that the real issues are elsewhere. For example, how the White House was briefed.

UPDATE: Alert reader Lucille says I mean "red herring." Not "tar baby." Well, I mean tar baby, since focusing on the 28 pages will suck up investigative resources, news cycles, blog space, etc., that could otherwise be focused on more important issues (like what did the White House know?)



People who lie surround themselves with liars

As, for example, our Dear Leader.

Tom Raum of the AP writes:

In the rising controversy over how the Bush administration built its case for war in Iraq, one curious fact stands out. Some who gave President Bush unwelcome information that turned out to be accurate are gone. Those who did the opposite are still around.

Loyalty, to Bush, means lying for him, to him, and enabling him in his own lies.

I'm sure theologians would find this interesting.



Do You Hear A Dog Not Barking?

In Sunday's WaPo, the obvious questions about Condi Rice's competence and honesty suggested by her role in the runup to the war with Iraq are raised by Dana Milbank and Mike Allen.

She has been made to appear out of the loop by colleagues' claims that she did not read or recall vital pieces of intelligence. And she has made statements about U.S. intelligence on Iraq that have been contradicted by facts that later emerged.

(edit)

Rice declined to be interviewed for this article. NSC officials said each of Rice's public statements is accurate. "It was and is the judgment of the intelligence community that Saddam Hussein was attempting to reconstitute his nuclear weapons program," said Michael Anton, an NSC spokesman.

Still, a person close to Rice said that she has been dismayed by the effect on Bush. "She knows she did badly by him, and he knows that she knows it," this person said.

(edit)

Bush aides have made clear that Rice's stature is undiminished in the president's eyes. The fault is one of a process in which speech vetting was not systematic enough, they said. "You cannot have a clearance process that depends on the memory of people who are bombarded with as much information, as much paperwork, as many meetings, as many phone calls," one official said. "You have to make sure everybody, each time, actually reads the documents. And if it's a presidential speech, it has to be done at the highest levels." (my italics)

Let us pause, for a moment, to ponder the raucous, sneering, skepticism, lasting a minimum of 7 news cycles, that such a response from the Clinton White House about any question raised, whether by Republicans or by the punditterati, however trivial, would have provoked. Compare, for instance, the case of Roger Altman and the miniscule transgression of congressional priviledge that forced his resignation.

Having said that, the story strikes me as both damning, and starting to feel old news-ish. I'm not being a pessimist. I agree with those readers who feel that a corner has been turned on the media's desire and ability to pre-exonerate this administration for every bad thing that happens on its watch.

I'm only observing that the time may have come to advance and enlarge this story into one that poses the essential question: Are this administration's answers to the challenge of 9/11 the right ones?

That it will fall to critics of the Bush doctrine rather than the mainstream media to do so is strongly suggested by the absence in this article of arguably the most crucial example of Ms. Rice's failure to tell the whole truth - her statement that there was no specific intelligence that could have led anyone in the Bush administation to so much as begin to imagine that anyone might be contemplating the hijacking of airliners for use as flying bombs to be crashed into major public buildings. No aspersion being cast here on either Milbank or Allen, but in a week in which the first comprehensive report on the wheres and the whyfores of 9/11, one might have hoped...

In lieu of that, see the italicized portions of this prior post, regarding Condi's Aug 6th, 2001 security briefing with the President in Texas, and put that information in this context, graciously provided by Paul of "Half-Baked Thoughts:"

2. Finding: During the spring and summer of 2001, the Intelligence Community experienced a significant increase in information indicating that Bin Ladin and al-Qa’ida intended to strike against U.S. interests in the very near future.

Discussion: The National Security Agency (NSA), for example, reported at least 33 communications indicating a possible, imminent terrorist attack in 2001

(edit)

Some Community personnel described the increase in threat reporting as unprecedented, at least in their own experience.

Fortunately, our side is so much better informed and organized than we were during the Big Dog's eight years. And he'd be the first one to say, don't look back and regret what wasn't done, look forward to what can and must be done.

A positive Democratic policy on Iraq

Alert reader BobNJ writes:

I'd really like to see the Democratic Party come up with a responsible exit strategy for Iraq along the lines of calling for a UN takeover, termination of all Halliburton and Bechtel contracts with the country.

Readers? Thoughts?

Rules of engagement for Saddam

Presumably, if we find Saddam and kill him, this time we'll be smart enough not to desecrate his body. There's a way of winning Islamic hearts and minds.

Is there anything to learn from the episode of killing Saddam's sons?

Suppose we get good intelligence and surround Saddam, just the way (in non-tinfoil-hat mode) we did his sons.

What should the rules of engagement be?

In particular, what should the goals of the operation be? Killing, or capture?

My view: Our national interest, and the interests of the Iraqi people, would best be served by capturing Saddam, doing the perp walk, and handing him over to the Hague for trial before the war crimes tribunal. The rules of engagement should be structured to optimize for this outcome.

UPDATE
Even neo-con tool Chalabi agrees:

''I think it is much better for the Iraqi people and for the world for Saddam to be caught alive and put on trial for the crimes he has committed against the people of Iraq, against neighbors of Iraq and against the world,'' he told the BBC.

And the flak this blog took, from Tacitus and others less nuanced in their modes of expression, for expressing a common-sense view that is now making its way toward becoming the CW ... Sigh ...



Ritual disclaimer and troll prophylactic. Saddam is evil. So were his sons.

9/11 report and "no smoking gun"

So how can we know there's "no smoking gun" when we can't look in every room in the house?

First, the 28 pages from the Saudis (with whom the Bush family has long had very tight relations) is redacted.

Second, we don't know what the White House knew and when they knew it.


Oh—and the biggest smoking gun of all—no AQ Iraq connection at all—YABL in the justification for the war.

As Carie Lenack of Families of September 11 told Jennifer Barret of Newsweek:

Carie Lemack: I was hoping we’d gain more information, but it doesn’t seem like we’re getting much more … I feel like, in an era where we’re holding CEOs accountable for losing $3 million, I’d hope we’d want to hold people accountable for losing 3,000 lives.
But the administration has still chosen to classify the part about who funded the terrorists. And the fact that President Bush has chosen to classify it for what he says is national security makes me question just whose security he is protecting: our nation’s or the Saudis’? (via Leah back)

There are three morals to the story in the 16 words fiasco:

First, the Bush administration has consistently distorted intelligence for political ends.

Second, Bush himself has problems taking responsibility when things don't work out well.

Third, Bush himself has problems with the truth.

The first two are all on full display in the handling of the 9/11 report. We'll have to see about the third.

Wolfie's chutzpah

Anton Ferreira of WaPowrites:

Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz Sunday defended the invasion of Iraq as an example of how the United States had to be prepared to act on "murky intelligence" in its war on terrorism.

Wolfowitz was asked in several television interviews about widespread criticism that Washington's rationale for the war -- charges that Iraq had chemical and biological weapons and was collaborating with Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda group -- appeared to have been built on shaky foundations.

No such weapons have been found and little concrete evidence has been presented of an al Qaeda link.

"The nature of terrorism is that intelligence about terrorism is murky," Wolfowitz, one of the architects of the Iraq war, said on the "Fox News Sunday" program.

Wolfie goes on Fox... That's courage!

Anyhow, as Wolfie must know, the issue is not that intelligence is "murky"—the issue is whether intelligence was distorted for political ends, which is exactly what happened. The 16 words kept floating to the top, even as the intelligence professionals tried to keep them out, exactly because Bush was determined to have his war, and sought to use any reason, no matter how flimsy.

Bush lies, soldiers die.

Condi-lie-za?

Dana Milbank and Mike Allen write:

But she has since become enmeshed in the controversy over the administration's use of intelligence about Iraq's weapons in the run-up to war. She has been made to appear out of the loop by colleagues' claims that she did not read or recall vital pieces of intelligence. And she has made statements about U.S. intelligence on Iraq that have been contradicted by facts that later emerged.

The remarks by Rice and her associates raise two uncomfortable possibilities for the national security adviser. Either she missed or overlooked numerous warnings from intelligence agencies seeking to put caveats on claims about Iraq's nuclear weapons program, or she made public claims that she knew to be false.

Most prominent is her claim that the White House had not heard about CIA doubts about an allegation that Iraq sought uranium in Africa before the charge landed in Bush's State of the Union address on Jan. 28; in fact, her National Security Council staff received two memos doubting the claim and a phone call from CIA Director George J. Tenet months before the speech. Various other of Rice's public characterizations of intelligence documents and agencies' positions have been similarly cast into doubt.

Funny how story of Saddam's sons sucked all the oxygen out of the 16 words fiasco, isn't it? (Not to mention the 9/11 report?)

Even though killing Uday, what's-his-face, and that 14 year old is likely to turn out to be a blip in the Iraqi insurgency, and both the 16 words and the 9/11 report go to the heart of this administration's abilities to keep the country safe.

Funny, life.

Administration to military wives: "Shut up"

Christian Davenport of WaPo writes:

Susan Peacock thought that the 400th Military Police Battalion Family Readiness Group was there to provide solace and support for spouses of soldiers shipped to Iraq.

But when she read her e-mail July 15, she was appalled at what she saw. Group leaders were playing what one later called "hardball" with the Columbia mother of two and other 400th family members.

"OK this has gone far enough!" they wrote. The message said that "certain people are getting their soldiers in trouble" and that the unit's e-mail list had been sent to the Pentagon "for possible security violations and will be closely monitored."

A few days earlier, Peacock had heard a news report about an explosion outside Baghdad, near where the 400th, her husband's unit, was based. Since he'd left this spring, she'd grown skeptical of the military's unfailingly rosy accounts of the 400th's status.

Desperately worried, she tried to get information about the blast from family support staff and Army officials at Fort Meade, where the 400th is based. But after three days of inquiries, Peacock said she still knew nothing.

That's when she decided the other wives of the 400th might want to know about the incident. She sent an e-mail telling everyone what she'd heard.

"Evidently everything is not fine," she said she wrote.

Goodness!

Funny how it's OK to use the troops as extras for Republican campaign events like Bush's infamous carrier landing stunt, but it's not OK for the troops to raise real issues on matters of life and death.

qWagmire

Richard Oppel of the Times writes:

Three American soldiers with the Fourth Infantry Division were killed and four were wounded here today after an assailant, who witnesses said was probably perched inside the children's hospital the troops were guarding, threw a grenade into a group of soldiers who were playing a game of cards next to the building.

Another American soldier was killed today and two others were wounded in an attack on an Army convoy in Abu Ghraib, just west of Baghdad, military officials said. And early Sunday, a soldier from the 1st Marine Expeditionary Force was killed in a grenade attack. A military spokesman had no details on the location of the attack.

The attack is a blow to hopes that the slaying in Mosul on Tuesday of Saddam Hussein's sons, Uday and Qusay, would weaken the resolve of Iraqi insurgents.

Well, what was killing Saddam's other than propaganda for the home front, anyhow? "It was a famous victory."

Ritual disclaimer and troll prophylactic: Saddam is evil, and so were his sons.

Calling up the Guard

On their way...