Wednesday, April 28, 2004

Where Left and Right Should Agree

The abuse of eminent domain is one issue that should anger people all across the ideological spectrum. Florida's going to legalize a massive land grab:

Florida’s constitution allows governments to take your land for a public purpose, such as a road or school, as long as you receive a fair price.

But legislation — which could be approved this week — would allow a city or county to take an individual’s land, with fair compensation, and sell it to a private developer for a shopping center or office building.

Opponents of the proposed law say it’s little more than a government-sponsored land grab for developers.

“This bill is a shocking grant of wholesale power to counties to condemn very large amounts of property just to assemble it for private development,” said Dana Berliner, senior attorney at the Washington, D.C.-based Institute for Justice, a public interest law firm.

Frank Schnidman, a professor of community and economic development at Florida Atlantic University and an expert in land planning, agreed.

“They basically want to loosen up the definition of public purpose so land can be taken for development,” he said.

Proponents say it’s necessary so that communities such as Cape Coral and Lehigh Acres, which have thousands of small residential lots and not enough commercial land, can ensure they have enough property for future businesses.

“For some of these communities it’s absolutely essential,” said Sen. Mike Bennett, R-Bradenton, the Senate bill sponsor.


No it isn't absolutely essential. Developers can assemble smaller pieces for commercial property and offer more money to get people to sell. The issue is that the land will be worth more after conversion to commerical use. Developers want to pay what it's worth before conversion, homeowners understandably want to get what it's really worth for the developers.


...john d'oh informs us that the eminent domain provision was removed. Judging from this article, I'm actually not quite sure of that. Looks like one senator was running around saying "trust me." We'll see...