I hope my rather flippant post below regarding Fortuyn wasn't misinterpreted. This is an incredibly unpleasant and disturbing development, both for supporters and detractors of the man. Apparently they have arrested a "white man of Dutch nationality" (whatever that means) but I haven't yet heard of a motive.
Fortuyn's problem, to the extent that I understand it, is not that he is anti-immigration, it is that he is anti-immigrant and anti-anyone who doesn't fit his idea of proper Dutchness. I, myself, am very pro-immigration with respect to this country - in fact, I would argue that increased immigration in the 90s did much to bring the country out of a cultural and economic stagnation. But, it is perfectly valid to be against immigration for whatever reason, even if some of those reasons might spring from ugly racist roots. But, it is not okay to campaign against the enemy within - to consign a portion of your legal population to the margins of society by pitting "us" against "them."
On the other hand, some European countries need to come to terms with a very real problem they have. Europeans I know generally try to pretend the issue isn't really there - or that it's simply a conflict between National Front types and immigrants, with the rest of the population simply washing their hands of the problem. In Slate, this passage is revealing:
Strangest of all, the touchy issue of France's large immigrant population, their alleged failure to assimilate, and their supposed responsibility for France's huge crime wave has received relatively few mentions in public. Even the postelection TV coverage on French state television—at least the first few hours of it—included virtually no mention of immigrants or immigration. Strangely, to my American eye, no Arab or black leaders had even been invited into the studio to offer instant comment on the results.
[aside: this of course is no different than our news media's almost complete failure to provide a platform to gay men to discuss/refute claimed links between homosexuality and pedophilia.]
France prides itself on the fact that they collect no race-based statistics of any kind, and though this attitude is somewhat laudable it is also both naive and damaging. There is no data, so there is no problem.
Of course, the fact this is of any concern to me is partially motivated by my annoyance of European smugness about those racist Americans. One friend who came to visit honestly seemed to believe that our entire African-American population was living in walled-off ghettos without indoor plumbing, and was genuinely shocked to discover that this was not the case.
Monday, May 06, 2002
Vaara wittily and succintly explains my concerns far better than I did about the new LA newspaper. He refers to the New York Sun as the world's first "dead-tree weblog" which is what one worries the Examiner will be.
Well, the Dutch Andy Sullivan*** is no more.
*** cheap shot, I know. And I already violated my oath. Ah well.
[update]: oops, that article says he's still alive. I swear I saw one that said he was dead, but I can't find it...
developing hard, as they say.
ah yes, here it is.
*** cheap shot, I know. And I already violated my oath. Ah well.
[update]: oops, that article says he's still alive. I swear I saw one that said he was dead, but I can't find it...
developing hard, as they say.
ah yes, here it is.
From: Seattle Times 5 May 2002
Gasoline Fumes
The Times quotes Mike Gwinn of Pomeroy, Washington, “We want nice roads as much as anybody, but it’s hard for me to vote for a tax.” It might interest your readers to know that according to the farm subsidy database available through the Environmental Working Group, “Michael & Alice Gwinn of Pomeroy, Washington” received USDA farm subsidies of $662,669 between 1996 and 2001. During the same period, farm subsidy recipients in Garfield County received $50,838,847. With the reported population of about 2,400, that works out to more than $21,000 per person. The story reports Gwinn buys 50 galIons per week; the 9-cent-per-gallon tax increase will cost him $234 per year.
Jeff Krautkraemer Pullman, Washington
Gasoline Fumes
The Times quotes Mike Gwinn of Pomeroy, Washington, “We want nice roads as much as anybody, but it’s hard for me to vote for a tax.” It might interest your readers to know that according to the farm subsidy database available through the Environmental Working Group, “Michael & Alice Gwinn of Pomeroy, Washington” received USDA farm subsidies of $662,669 between 1996 and 2001. During the same period, farm subsidy recipients in Garfield County received $50,838,847. With the reported population of about 2,400, that works out to more than $21,000 per person. The story reports Gwinn buys 50 galIons per week; the 9-cent-per-gallon tax increase will cost him $234 per year.
Jeff Krautkraemer Pullman, Washington
This is also a bit late. But, havng read back through a bunch of bloggers' backlogs... why is that everyone feels qualified to comment on the Cornel West issue?
Seriously. Please. Let me know. Also, let me know what other fields you feel qualified to comment on. Also, let me know which other high profile academic moves you've discussed recently.
Seriously. Please. Let me know. Also, let me know what other fields you feel qualified to comment on. Also, let me know which other high profile academic moves you've discussed recently.
From the Department of Dignitude:
I really don't know what to say about this I think it speaks for itself really.
Late last month, a quarter-million households received an official-looking brown envelope, with a return address on the front identifying it as a "REGISTERED CENSUS DOCUMENT." Large letters next to the address window commanded, "DO NOT BEND." Adding to the governmental imprimatur, the second and third lines of the return address read, "Penalty for Private Use (Rev. 3/95)."
Imagine the surprise when the enclosure turned out to be the National Republican Senatorial Committee "Chairman's Census," with tough questions such as these: "Did you know that Republicans must defend 20 seats and Democrats only defend 14? Are you aware that the progress of the Bush Administration is currently being completely obstructed by Tom Daschle and his Democratic Senate majority? Are you prepared to help us win this fight?"
The four-page enclosed letter from the committee chairman, Sen. Bill Frist (R-Tenn.), like the "Census" form, concluded with a standard pitch for contributions from $25 up.
Asked about the deceptive envelope, committee officials shifted the responsibility to an unidentified private direct-mail vendor. "We have an elaborate sign-off system for every piece of mail that goes out," said NRSC spokeswoman Ginny Wolfe, "but we never looked at the envelope. From now on, we will."
I really don't know what to say about this I think it speaks for itself really.
Late last month, a quarter-million households received an official-looking brown envelope, with a return address on the front identifying it as a "REGISTERED CENSUS DOCUMENT." Large letters next to the address window commanded, "DO NOT BEND." Adding to the governmental imprimatur, the second and third lines of the return address read, "Penalty for Private Use (Rev. 3/95)."
Imagine the surprise when the enclosure turned out to be the National Republican Senatorial Committee "Chairman's Census," with tough questions such as these: "Did you know that Republicans must defend 20 seats and Democrats only defend 14? Are you aware that the progress of the Bush Administration is currently being completely obstructed by Tom Daschle and his Democratic Senate majority? Are you prepared to help us win this fight?"
The four-page enclosed letter from the committee chairman, Sen. Bill Frist (R-Tenn.), like the "Census" form, concluded with a standard pitch for contributions from $25 up.
Asked about the deceptive envelope, committee officials shifted the responsibility to an unidentified private direct-mail vendor. "We have an elaborate sign-off system for every piece of mail that goes out," said NRSC spokeswoman Ginny Wolfe, "but we never looked at the envelope. From now on, we will."
This has been oft-quoted in Blogistan. But, Hey, I'm fairly new to this country, and maybe some of my readers are as well, so I thought I'd recycle this already WEEK-OLD bit by Charles Dodgson:
The true Bush diplomatic strategy, they claim, is deep and complex, and cannot be understood by simply taking the administration's public positions at face value. It is an elaborate series of bluffs, feints, and jabs, a kind of diplomatic blindfold chess, at once treacherous and Machiavellian in its methods, and nobly Jeffersonian in its outlook and aspirations--which just happens to require, at this point in time, in service of its recondite tactics, that the President appear to be a dim-witted rube who agrees with whatever he most recently heard from anyone with a manly voice and a firm handshake.
as linked by Electrolite.
P.S. Dodgson was kind enough to write me a nice email that I have failed to respond to, only because it required too much thinking and my brain has been hurting lately....
The true Bush diplomatic strategy, they claim, is deep and complex, and cannot be understood by simply taking the administration's public positions at face value. It is an elaborate series of bluffs, feints, and jabs, a kind of diplomatic blindfold chess, at once treacherous and Machiavellian in its methods, and nobly Jeffersonian in its outlook and aspirations--which just happens to require, at this point in time, in service of its recondite tactics, that the President appear to be a dim-witted rube who agrees with whatever he most recently heard from anyone with a manly voice and a firm handshake.
as linked by Electrolite.
P.S. Dodgson was kind enough to write me a nice email that I have failed to respond to, only because it required too much thinking and my brain has been hurting lately....
Sunday, May 05, 2002
I have a theory about Andrew Sullivan.
Hear me out.
Andrew Sullivan is the ultimate troll. And, no, I’m not referring to his outlandish neck.
Anyone who has spent time on message boards on the internet knows what a troll is. They have various methods, but their primary purpose is to shut down any interesting discussion. Some use rather thuggish methods – spamming forums with racist comments and obscenities. On moderated forums this doesn’t work, so they’ve had to develop more subtle methods.
One brand of troll is the “Energy Creature.” Their particular skill is somehow managing to shift the focus of all conversation to them.
One way to do this is to make a somewhat (but not too) outrageous claim. When people refute it they demand proof. When proof is provided they demand more proof. When you provide absolutely irrefutable proof they claim they meant something else, which is also false. So, then you finally manage to prove them wrong (After a few tries, of course). Then, three days later they again state their outrageous claim as if it is fact and the conversation never happened.
After a few rounds of this, of course, people get wise to them and start ignoring them. So, they start being reasonable for a while, and buttering people up. They can be charming when they want to, so they get other people to be sympathetic to them. They play nice for a bit, and then just when others have decided they’re a bit reasonable…they start back up again.
Well, anyway, you get the idea. Using this, and other methods, they eventually manage to enrage people on all sides and completely destroy a forum. The only way to get them to go away is to stop feeding these energy creatures by completely ignore them.
I think Andy Sullivan is trying to shut down the left wing (what little there is) of the punditocracy. Michael Kinsley recently stated that you could waste an entire career swatting flies off the Wall Street Journal editorial page. But, they’re so ridiculous that one quickly tires of the exercise. Andy’s more skilled than that. He knows how to be just interesting enough and just reasonable enough to keep people come back for more again and again. Besides, it’s so easy he makes it kind of fun.
But, I think it is time to stop wasting time on this ridiculous individual. There have to be more important things to do than swat flies off the Daily Dish.
So, left wing pundits and bloggers unite with me! Take the pledge! From now on, ignore Andy Sullivan! Do not take the bait!
Do not feed the energy creature!
And maybe he’ll just go away…
ah, I know I won't be able to resist...damnit
Hear me out.
Andrew Sullivan is the ultimate troll. And, no, I’m not referring to his outlandish neck.
Anyone who has spent time on message boards on the internet knows what a troll is. They have various methods, but their primary purpose is to shut down any interesting discussion. Some use rather thuggish methods – spamming forums with racist comments and obscenities. On moderated forums this doesn’t work, so they’ve had to develop more subtle methods.
One brand of troll is the “Energy Creature.” Their particular skill is somehow managing to shift the focus of all conversation to them.
One way to do this is to make a somewhat (but not too) outrageous claim. When people refute it they demand proof. When proof is provided they demand more proof. When you provide absolutely irrefutable proof they claim they meant something else, which is also false. So, then you finally manage to prove them wrong (After a few tries, of course). Then, three days later they again state their outrageous claim as if it is fact and the conversation never happened.
After a few rounds of this, of course, people get wise to them and start ignoring them. So, they start being reasonable for a while, and buttering people up. They can be charming when they want to, so they get other people to be sympathetic to them. They play nice for a bit, and then just when others have decided they’re a bit reasonable…they start back up again.
Well, anyway, you get the idea. Using this, and other methods, they eventually manage to enrage people on all sides and completely destroy a forum. The only way to get them to go away is to stop feeding these energy creatures by completely ignore them.
I think Andy Sullivan is trying to shut down the left wing (what little there is) of the punditocracy. Michael Kinsley recently stated that you could waste an entire career swatting flies off the Wall Street Journal editorial page. But, they’re so ridiculous that one quickly tires of the exercise. Andy’s more skilled than that. He knows how to be just interesting enough and just reasonable enough to keep people come back for more again and again. Besides, it’s so easy he makes it kind of fun.
But, I think it is time to stop wasting time on this ridiculous individual. There have to be more important things to do than swat flies off the Daily Dish.
So, left wing pundits and bloggers unite with me! Take the pledge! From now on, ignore Andy Sullivan! Do not take the bait!
Do not feed the energy creature!
And maybe he’ll just go away…
ah, I know I won't be able to resist...damnit
Some cretin is giving a bizarre commentary on CNN's "Business Unusual." Basically, he's attacking the French for subsidizing their film industry. That's fine, but he's making the broader point that they need to choose between "global capitalism" and, well, I guess "not global capitalism." I get so tired of the mass delusion that's perpetuated in this country that somehow we have no tarriffs and no subsidies and everyone else does. Our farm subsidies are larger (and growing ever larger) than Europe's. Our television networks are subsidized with free spots on the spectrum. Movie production is regularly subsidized, if not by the Feds, by the various state and local governments that offer them inducements to come. We have steel tariffs. We have textile tariffs. We have agricultural tariffs. The list goes on and on and on and on...
Vaara (yes, I know how incestual this is getting, but us sophomoric liberal airheads need to stick together) has an excellent post about the book Coloring the Media. I also have not read the book, but in the meta-verse we now reside that of course does not disqualify me from expressing an opinion.
I do not know why the book did not get more attention than it did. I suppose we can be thankful that it wasn’t given the Bias treatment. Perhaps it was simply the timing, or perhaps the book is as ridiculous and loathsome as it sounds.
I do have some exposure to the author, so I can comment on that. I had the misfortune of hearing him on a local NPR talk show. The host, who is fairly bright but nonconfrontational let him present his views, though a few callers did challenge him.
First of all, the guy is obviously a bully with a grudge. He was a jerk to the host who wasn’t pushing him very hard, and a complete jerk to the callers who tried to. Like many of his ilk, he considers his critics to be the racist bigots, and not him. His main thesis seemed to be simply that affirmative action in the newsroom had led to a proliferation of minorities in the newsroom and this brown mob that had infected the place refused to allow stories to be run that were critical of minority communities. Or something like that.
Of course, his premise is wrong and his conclusion is just silly. Though many of the top newspapers have increased their minority hiring, minorities are still often underrepresented. Last I checked, broadly defined non-whites made up 30% of the population nationally. Not everyone gets a picture by their by-line, but I don’t think 30% or more is too common in even the major newspapers. And, once you get below the major markets, most of the smaller dailies – from which the great mass of the country gets their news – have abominable records on minority hires.
As for his conclusion, well… There are plenty of stories that editors do not want to cover. Exhibit A: The Catholic Church sex scandals. Of course, now it is covered because eventually a certain threshold was crossed. But, it was given scant attention for years. What editor of a Boston paper would want to be the first to take that one on? Locally, the shenanigans of our Business Elite are regularly not covered at all in the Orange County Register. If not for the only recently established weekly alternative rag, it would be as if the criminal and civil trials of some of these folks didn’t happen at all. Local political and business corruption is almost completely ignored by the daily, even when there are arrests and court dates. Unless, of course, Loretta Sanchez is somehow involved.
We all know that media is not the sacred cow it pretends to be – that financial and other considerations govern what is and isn't reported, and how. But, this book puts McGowan in the same category as Ann Coulter who recently claimed that white males have no political power in this country. Even if some of his specific allegations of biased coverage are true, the notion that the subversive influence of minorities on the news can even come close to outmatching the influence of the entrenched interest groups – white males and the local political, business, and religious community– is utterly ludicrous.
If you give these people enough credit to allow that they might actually believe what they say, and aren’t simply Horowitz-style propaganda-writing whores, then this belief can only stem from a firmly installed belief that “Whiteness” is the norm, and all of its biases and transgressions are somehow unimportant, while any inroads by minorities into the media and politics is somehow less valid and deserving of more scrutiny. I’m sure minorities bring their biases and personal agendas into the newsroom no more or less than anyone involved in the media. It doesn’t mean that these things don’t deserve some scrutiny, but placing such emphasis on them folks without acknowledging the fact that, by and large, there’s much more whiting out of the media than coloring, betrays an inherent profound bigotry of white entitlement.
I do not know why the book did not get more attention than it did. I suppose we can be thankful that it wasn’t given the Bias treatment. Perhaps it was simply the timing, or perhaps the book is as ridiculous and loathsome as it sounds.
I do have some exposure to the author, so I can comment on that. I had the misfortune of hearing him on a local NPR talk show. The host, who is fairly bright but nonconfrontational let him present his views, though a few callers did challenge him.
First of all, the guy is obviously a bully with a grudge. He was a jerk to the host who wasn’t pushing him very hard, and a complete jerk to the callers who tried to. Like many of his ilk, he considers his critics to be the racist bigots, and not him. His main thesis seemed to be simply that affirmative action in the newsroom had led to a proliferation of minorities in the newsroom and this brown mob that had infected the place refused to allow stories to be run that were critical of minority communities. Or something like that.
Of course, his premise is wrong and his conclusion is just silly. Though many of the top newspapers have increased their minority hiring, minorities are still often underrepresented. Last I checked, broadly defined non-whites made up 30% of the population nationally. Not everyone gets a picture by their by-line, but I don’t think 30% or more is too common in even the major newspapers. And, once you get below the major markets, most of the smaller dailies – from which the great mass of the country gets their news – have abominable records on minority hires.
As for his conclusion, well… There are plenty of stories that editors do not want to cover. Exhibit A: The Catholic Church sex scandals. Of course, now it is covered because eventually a certain threshold was crossed. But, it was given scant attention for years. What editor of a Boston paper would want to be the first to take that one on? Locally, the shenanigans of our Business Elite are regularly not covered at all in the Orange County Register. If not for the only recently established weekly alternative rag, it would be as if the criminal and civil trials of some of these folks didn’t happen at all. Local political and business corruption is almost completely ignored by the daily, even when there are arrests and court dates. Unless, of course, Loretta Sanchez is somehow involved.
We all know that media is not the sacred cow it pretends to be – that financial and other considerations govern what is and isn't reported, and how. But, this book puts McGowan in the same category as Ann Coulter who recently claimed that white males have no political power in this country. Even if some of his specific allegations of biased coverage are true, the notion that the subversive influence of minorities on the news can even come close to outmatching the influence of the entrenched interest groups – white males and the local political, business, and religious community– is utterly ludicrous.
If you give these people enough credit to allow that they might actually believe what they say, and aren’t simply Horowitz-style propaganda-writing whores, then this belief can only stem from a firmly installed belief that “Whiteness” is the norm, and all of its biases and transgressions are somehow unimportant, while any inroads by minorities into the media and politics is somehow less valid and deserving of more scrutiny. I’m sure minorities bring their biases and personal agendas into the newsroom no more or less than anyone involved in the media. It doesn’t mean that these things don’t deserve some scrutiny, but placing such emphasis on them folks without acknowledging the fact that, by and large, there’s much more whiting out of the media than coloring, betrays an inherent profound bigotry of white entitlement.
Following up on my new pet project below regarding Luis Giusti, this article from the Houston Chronicle about a conference of energy experts, while not proving a White House connection, does seem kind of comical now:
Other participants included Enron Corp. Chairman Ken Lay; Dynegy Chief Executive Chuck Watson; former Deputy
Energy Secretary Bill White; former Deputy Energy Secretary Charles Curtis; Houston earth scientist and engineer
Michel Halbouty; Simmons & Co. President Matthew Simmons; ChevronTexaco Chief Executive David O'Reilly;
former Petroleos de Venezuela Chairman Luis Giusti; and Cambridge Energy Research Associates Chairman Daniel
Yergin.
Oh, and James Baker was there, of course.
Other participants included Enron Corp. Chairman Ken Lay; Dynegy Chief Executive Chuck Watson; former Deputy
Energy Secretary Bill White; former Deputy Energy Secretary Charles Curtis; Houston earth scientist and engineer
Michel Halbouty; Simmons & Co. President Matthew Simmons; ChevronTexaco Chief Executive David O'Reilly;
former Petroleos de Venezuela Chairman Luis Giusti; and Cambridge Energy Research Associates Chairman Daniel
Yergin.
Oh, and James Baker was there, of course.
How embarassing must it be to have to parse the nuances of the Bush Doctrine, as Condi Rice is attempting to do now on Late Edition.
If I were conducting that interview I would have collapsed into giggles by now.
I mean, we're supposed to take seriously a foreign policy with a guiding principle of (in Condi's words, roughly): "he did say that if you continue to harbor terrorists then you are against us.."?
If I were conducting that interview I would have collapsed into giggles by now.
I mean, we're supposed to take seriously a foreign policy with a guiding principle of (in Condi's words, roughly): "he did say that if you continue to harbor terrorists then you are against us.."?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
