Yes, I know that Joe Conason is the pariah of punditry, a Clinton apologist . But, let's take a peek at this week's article in the Observer::
If you remember that terrible "energy crisis"
in California a year or so ago, then you may
also recall that everybody who is anybody
had a strong opinion about
its causes and cures.
Actually, most members of
the opinionated elite were
promoting the same conservative certitudes:
They exonerated the likes of Enron, blamed
environmentalists and regulators, and
mocked any hint of market manipulation by
the energy industry.
As of last week, however, with the exposure of internal
Enron documents that describe the market-rigging strategies
nicknamed "Fat Boy," "Death Star" and "Get Shorty," we
have a clearer idea of what really happened. Now we have
seen proof, in memos written by Enron’s own lawyers, that
the West Coast energy crisis was exacerbated by the
powermongers, perhaps by criminal means. Now we know
about the trading schemes used by Enron to game the
California system, even at the risk of dangerous blackouts.
Now we are learning that deregulation permitted Enron, and
apparently other firms, to "launder" electricity and falsify
congestion on the power grid, in order to rob tens of billions
of dollars from California consumers and businesses.
So we also know now that those dominant voices in the
media, braying about the infallibility of the market, were
loudly, confidently and completely wrong. And who were
they again?
Aside from the nation’s conservative editorial pages—which
is to say, most of them—the defenders of the energy traders
rampaged across the op-ed columns and magazine pages.
Texas Monthly reassured the home folks that Enron and
Reliant Energy were innocent, deriding California as "whine
country." Oil & Gas Daily agreed that the Californians
themselves were "the real culprits in the energy drama."
In the Washington Post, Charles Krauthammer assured
readers that only "silly" Californians "think that the rolling
blackouts are a conspiracy by the power companies to raise
rates." And William Safire, in an almost incomprehensible
column that termed the rise and fall of prices "as natural as
breathing," warned that "populist interference with the
[electricity] market’s self-correction would lead to worse
shortages and rationing, to inflation and wage control." That
was a scary prediction from the sage of The New York
Times—and also utterly, totally, ridiculously wrong.
I hope Welch and Layne don't devote tomorrow's blogging to the deconstruction of Joe Conason. Hey, even if he's wrong, isn't there anything better to do?
But, note to Welch and Layne: Read The Hunting of the President. Read Fools for Scandal. Read David Brocks's illuminating, if imperfect, Blinded by the Right. Read your most hated left-wing pundit's Sound and Fury. Hell, while you're at it, read Susan Faludi's Backlash.
Wednesday, May 15, 2002
Tuesday, May 14, 2002
Just to follow up, I see this post by Ken Layne says this:
Just more proof that there are only two political sides in the world: Smart and Dumb.
Sorry, Ken, the difference between Tom DeLay and Al Gore isn't a matter of Smart and Dumb. You can spend all day stroking each others' egos with a round of "anti-idiotarian" backslapping, but there are vastly different political viewpoints out there which have little or nothing to do with the intelligence or debating club skills of their proponents.
Just more proof that there are only two political sides in the world: Smart and Dumb.
Sorry, Ken, the difference between Tom DeLay and Al Gore isn't a matter of Smart and Dumb. You can spend all day stroking each others' egos with a round of "anti-idiotarian" backslapping, but there are vastly different political viewpoints out there which have little or nothing to do with the intelligence or debating club skills of their proponents.
AintNoBadDude (whose permalinks aren't working) wonders why no one from the "Left" mounts a vigorous defense of their liberal/Democratic positions. Well, I had no idea that Matt Welch and Ken Layne were liberals until I noticed that they called themselves liberals. It isn't because they spend time on their blogs advocating a conservative agenda, it's because they spend all their time on their blogs ridiculing anyone to the Left of them. Hey, guys, no need - Sully, Jonah Goldberg, and practically everyone else in Blogsitan have got that beat covered. What, you think you need to establish your street cred so Instapundit and Tim Blair take you seriously? Is one more post criticizing Robert Fisk and Noam Chomsky, who only the 2.5% (generous estimate) that make up the Lefty fringe in this country pay any attention to , really adding anything to the debate? Leave the Right's favorite whipping boys to them. By continuing to talk about them you give credit to the idea that Al Gore and Noam Chomsky are one and the same, as Sully would have us believe, or that the Fifth Column in this country is headed by Terry MacAulliffe.
If you want to join in with Mickey Kaus and devote your existence to making the world safe for centrist Democrats, even though the vast majority of liberals in the media and in reality are centrist Democrats, feel free. But, when I started reading your Blogs I thought you were part of the Vast Instapundit Right Wing Conspiracy.
The Loony Left in this country is so much more marginalized than the Loony Right. It's mostly a mutual masturbation society with little wider influence. Isn't there anything better to do than attack Robert Fisk? He doesn't even write for a freakin' U.S. paper! Turn your guns on Jonah Goldberg or George Will or William Safire or Charles Krauthammer or Mike Kelly or Andy Sullivan or ....
If you want to join in with Mickey Kaus and devote your existence to making the world safe for centrist Democrats, even though the vast majority of liberals in the media and in reality are centrist Democrats, feel free. But, when I started reading your Blogs I thought you were part of the Vast Instapundit Right Wing Conspiracy.
The Loony Left in this country is so much more marginalized than the Loony Right. It's mostly a mutual masturbation society with little wider influence. Isn't there anything better to do than attack Robert Fisk? He doesn't even write for a freakin' U.S. paper! Turn your guns on Jonah Goldberg or George Will or William Safire or Charles Krauthammer or Mike Kelly or Andy Sullivan or ....
Richard Goldstein weighs in on homocons on both sides of the pond.
excerpt:
Now that he's pushing up tulips, conservatives have rushed to rehabilitate Fortuyn. Here in the States, he's been embraced by neocons as a martyr, the Matthew Shepard of the managerial class. All the more reason to pin Pim's politics down.
Was he a fascist? Not as we understand the word (though fascism might be facilitated by his rise). But he certainly was a right-winger. In America, any conservative could run on his platform, stripped of its planks on personal liberty. Fortuyn advocated slashing the public sector, cutting taxes, and cracking down on crime. Substitute African Americans for immigrants as Fortuyn did, could hope to lead the party of Ollie North. Imagine a politician who made a positive issue of his homosexuality getting a serious crack at the White House.
It was Fortuyn's good fortune to be a citizen of the world's only free state for gay people. But that doesn't mean his perspective was uniquely Dutch. Beyond his immigrant bashing, Pim had much in common with an American homocon like Andrew Sullivan. Both men rose in the liberal media of their countries by professing to be talking common sense, not ideology. Yet both belong to a new kind of conservatism that springs from the love that dare not vote Republican.
excerpt:
Now that he's pushing up tulips, conservatives have rushed to rehabilitate Fortuyn. Here in the States, he's been embraced by neocons as a martyr, the Matthew Shepard of the managerial class. All the more reason to pin Pim's politics down.
Was he a fascist? Not as we understand the word (though fascism might be facilitated by his rise). But he certainly was a right-winger. In America, any conservative could run on his platform, stripped of its planks on personal liberty. Fortuyn advocated slashing the public sector, cutting taxes, and cracking down on crime. Substitute African Americans for immigrants as Fortuyn did, could hope to lead the party of Ollie North. Imagine a politician who made a positive issue of his homosexuality getting a serious crack at the White House.
It was Fortuyn's good fortune to be a citizen of the world's only free state for gay people. But that doesn't mean his perspective was uniquely Dutch. Beyond his immigrant bashing, Pim had much in common with an American homocon like Andrew Sullivan. Both men rose in the liberal media of their countries by professing to be talking common sense, not ideology. Yet both belong to a new kind of conservatism that springs from the love that dare not vote Republican.
Whatever financial troubles The American Prospect has, I don't think they've managed to lose four billion dollars like News Corp has. (Yes, I know, not really an appropriate comparison).
However, where are Mickey Kaus's screeds attacking the Washington Times for losing A Billion Dollars over 15 years. The New York Post is reputed to lose between $20-30 million annually.
Why so quiet, Mickey? I look forward to your articles ridiculing Rupert Murdoch and the Reverend Moon for their financial folly.
However, where are Mickey Kaus's screeds attacking the Washington Times for losing A Billion Dollars over 15 years. The New York Post is reputed to lose between $20-30 million annually.
Why so quiet, Mickey? I look forward to your articles ridiculing Rupert Murdoch and the Reverend Moon for their financial folly.
Speaking of MaxSpeak he has the best zinger about Joe Klein's incredibly stupid article in Slate about populism:
This is one column that Joe Klein should have signed as “Anonymous.”
While we're on Joe Klein.... I liked Primary Colors. I thought it was quite an affectionate satire of the 1992 Democratic primaries and not the mean-spirited attack that many seemed to think it was. And, I understand the desire to be Anonymous. But, the subsequent games he played while editor shoulda bounced him outta his career for awhile.
This is one column that Joe Klein should have signed as “Anonymous.”
While we're on Joe Klein.... I liked Primary Colors. I thought it was quite an affectionate satire of the 1992 Democratic primaries and not the mean-spirited attack that many seemed to think it was. And, I understand the desire to be Anonymous. But, the subsequent games he played while editor shoulda bounced him outta his career for awhile.
Signorile has a great article about the American Right's bizarre reaction to Fortuyn.
Many good parts, but here's one:
I mean, really–suddenly, the hyperconservative Wall Street
Journal editorial page is holding up someone who, as the
editors describe him, wanted "to preserve Holland’s liberal
traditions"? The Wall Street Journal editorial page is
lauding a gay man who took on religious extremists? Gee,
quite a few gay men, pundits and politicians alike, have
been doing just that for quite some time when it comes to
Christian fundamentalists, but they’ve curiously not been
lauded by the WSJ editorial page. In fact, the editors have
often given their pages over to the religious extremists
themselves to do their bashing.
In the Netherlands, meanwhile, Islamic fundamentalists
don’t have even one iota of the political power that
Christian fundamentalists have in America. Fortuyn
appears to have been using his own homosexuality and
gay rights in general to scapegoat a growing immigrant
group that many Dutch have been fearful about, and it was
playing quite well. But it is not a group that, within the
political machine, seems anywhere near as close to
effecting gay rights in the Netherlands as the Christian right
is to preventing the implementation of rights for gays in
America (and to turning back women’s rights). In the
reports I’ve read none spoke of a slew of other politicians
championing the Islamic fundamentalists’ positions and
calling for taking away gays’ and women’s rights. In this
country, however, the President himself has stated that he
supports the Christian fundamentalists’ positions,
advocating an end to abortion rights and supporting
sodomy laws against homosexuals and barring them from
marrying and from adopting children.
Why haven’t we heard the Wall Street Journal editorial
page or National Review’s Rod Dreher standing up to
antigay religious extremism here in the way they’re so
concerned about it across the Atlantic? And if religious
fundamentalism poses such a demographic threat to a
nation’s well-being when it comes to immigration, are the
conservative pundits now ready to call for an end to
immigration by Christian fundamentalists to America?
The more questions you ask, the more suspect the
conservative pundits’ canonization of Pim Fortuyn
becomes.
Many good parts, but here's one:
I mean, really–suddenly, the hyperconservative Wall Street
Journal editorial page is holding up someone who, as the
editors describe him, wanted "to preserve Holland’s liberal
traditions"? The Wall Street Journal editorial page is
lauding a gay man who took on religious extremists? Gee,
quite a few gay men, pundits and politicians alike, have
been doing just that for quite some time when it comes to
Christian fundamentalists, but they’ve curiously not been
lauded by the WSJ editorial page. In fact, the editors have
often given their pages over to the religious extremists
themselves to do their bashing.
In the Netherlands, meanwhile, Islamic fundamentalists
don’t have even one iota of the political power that
Christian fundamentalists have in America. Fortuyn
appears to have been using his own homosexuality and
gay rights in general to scapegoat a growing immigrant
group that many Dutch have been fearful about, and it was
playing quite well. But it is not a group that, within the
political machine, seems anywhere near as close to
effecting gay rights in the Netherlands as the Christian right
is to preventing the implementation of rights for gays in
America (and to turning back women’s rights). In the
reports I’ve read none spoke of a slew of other politicians
championing the Islamic fundamentalists’ positions and
calling for taking away gays’ and women’s rights. In this
country, however, the President himself has stated that he
supports the Christian fundamentalists’ positions,
advocating an end to abortion rights and supporting
sodomy laws against homosexuals and barring them from
marrying and from adopting children.
Why haven’t we heard the Wall Street Journal editorial
page or National Review’s Rod Dreher standing up to
antigay religious extremism here in the way they’re so
concerned about it across the Atlantic? And if religious
fundamentalism poses such a demographic threat to a
nation’s well-being when it comes to immigration, are the
conservative pundits now ready to call for an end to
immigration by Christian fundamentalists to America?
The more questions you ask, the more suspect the
conservative pundits’ canonization of Pim Fortuyn
becomes.
He doesn't need a plug from me, since Josh Marshall linked him, and presumably Marshall gets at least 3-5 more hits per day than I do, but in any case a great weblog is MaxSpeak.
You know, I'm all for criticizing liberal and Democratic pundits and politicians, and I do it myself, but why is it that so many self-proclaimed liberals in Blogistan seem to do nothing else?
I know it is how you get Instapundit to pat you on the head and tell you that you're an "anti-idiotarian," but who above the age of 15 would use a term like that?
It sounds like the name of a club that a bunch of dorks in high school who can't get dates form after stumbling across the writings of Ayn Rand...
Hmmmm.....
I know it is how you get Instapundit to pat you on the head and tell you that you're an "anti-idiotarian," but who above the age of 15 would use a term like that?
It sounds like the name of a club that a bunch of dorks in high school who can't get dates form after stumbling across the writings of Ayn Rand...
Hmmmm.....
Mailbox bomb in Philly. Apparently the one yesterday had a note which said "free Palestine" and mentioned al-Qaeda. I doubt this has anything to do with al-Qaeda. My guess is that it is a homegrown anti-Semitic nutball, but we'll see...
[UPDATE: Confirming my suspicions, CNN reporting that al-Qaeda was ridiculously misspelled.]
[UPDATE: Confirming my suspicions, CNN reporting that al-Qaeda was ridiculously misspelled.]
Mickey Kaus loves to beat up on the American Prospect. Hey, I've made a few swipes at it myself (though TAPPED is great, as evidenced by the fact that Glenn Reynolds is spending an inordinate amount of time nitpicking it). But to beat up on it for its failure to break even is a bit silly. Why doesn't he make the same point about the New York Post, the Washington Times, and (presumably) The Weekly Standard and National Review.
I posted this over at Oliver Willis' page in response to his comment in response to Matt Welch's comment on this LA Times editorial, but it ended up being long enough that I figured I'd repeat it here:
Castro has been far less evil (and murderous) and far better to his people than Castro-haters in Miami, Nebraska, or Los Angeles are willing to admit. As dictators go, he's probably the best one there is - though admittedly he doesn't exactly have much competition. People in Nebraska have far more reason to hate the Chinese leadership than Castro. And, many of the economic problems have arisen from the embargo which post Cold-War there is zero justification for.
Miami Castro-haters have always been the biggest impediment to getting rid of Castro, and when he dies they will be the biggest impediment to the democratization of Cuba and the normalization of relations with the U.S. They, and their descendants (and some multinational companies), will try and demand that their property be returned, which much like Palestinian Right of Return demands, regardless of the merits, isn't going to happen.
Attempts to exploit uncertainties by the Miami mob after Castro's death will justify an authoritarian crackdown by the next leadership, much as the U.S.'s attempt to battle Castro after the revolution justified it for him.
As for Welch's assertion that Castro has concentration camps for homosexuals - when I was there I had a delightful time with openly gay men and women who were friends of a Cuban-American friend. Openly in that they publicly wore pink triangle pins. And, there was a mini gay-pride parade through Havana which seemed to be a fairly regular occurrence.
As for concentration camps for HIV+ Cubans... This is overdoing it a bit too as this makes clear. Concentration camps were places where 6 million+ Jews, Gypsies, Homosexuals, and other undesirables were gassed or killed by other means (not withstanding the claims of David Irving and his good friend Chris Hitchens). The sanitoriums in Cuba, though mandatory, provide the best possible medical care that Cuba has to offer. People are allowed out on weekends, and increasingly being allowed to have normalized lives. It was more of an overreaction to a potential public health crisis, not unlike what some proposed in this country at the time, than prison.I'm not defending them completely, but they shouldn't be mischaracterized. They're no Auschwitz, nor even Japanese-American internment camps.
Castro has been far less evil (and murderous) and far better to his people than Castro-haters in Miami, Nebraska, or Los Angeles are willing to admit. As dictators go, he's probably the best one there is - though admittedly he doesn't exactly have much competition. People in Nebraska have far more reason to hate the Chinese leadership than Castro. And, many of the economic problems have arisen from the embargo which post Cold-War there is zero justification for.
Miami Castro-haters have always been the biggest impediment to getting rid of Castro, and when he dies they will be the biggest impediment to the democratization of Cuba and the normalization of relations with the U.S. They, and their descendants (and some multinational companies), will try and demand that their property be returned, which much like Palestinian Right of Return demands, regardless of the merits, isn't going to happen.
Attempts to exploit uncertainties by the Miami mob after Castro's death will justify an authoritarian crackdown by the next leadership, much as the U.S.'s attempt to battle Castro after the revolution justified it for him.
As for Welch's assertion that Castro has concentration camps for homosexuals - when I was there I had a delightful time with openly gay men and women who were friends of a Cuban-American friend. Openly in that they publicly wore pink triangle pins. And, there was a mini gay-pride parade through Havana which seemed to be a fairly regular occurrence.
As for concentration camps for HIV+ Cubans... This is overdoing it a bit too as this makes clear. Concentration camps were places where 6 million+ Jews, Gypsies, Homosexuals, and other undesirables were gassed or killed by other means (not withstanding the claims of David Irving and his good friend Chris Hitchens). The sanitoriums in Cuba, though mandatory, provide the best possible medical care that Cuba has to offer. People are allowed out on weekends, and increasingly being allowed to have normalized lives. It was more of an overreaction to a potential public health crisis, not unlike what some proposed in this country at the time, than prison.I'm not defending them completely, but they shouldn't be mischaracterized. They're no Auschwitz, nor even Japanese-American internment camps.
CNN's coverage of Cuba (not referring to the Carter visit in particular, but the associated coverage of Cuba itself) has been surprisingly positive - too positive, if anything. But, it has also been pretty ignorant. Just now the anchor expressed shock that "Carter's speech will be aired live and uncensored!"
Cuba obviously isn't a model of free speech and free press, far from it, but it isn't North Korea either.
Cuba obviously isn't a model of free speech and free press, far from it, but it isn't North Korea either.
Monday, May 13, 2002
Conservative Crackup Alert!!
The Bull Moose commits ultimate sin! Calls Clinton a conservative! Says Conservatives may come to miss him! Will soon lose his keys to the VRWC executive washroom!
Bill Clinton, Conservative. The Moose muses that, up until this point, the previous Presidency may be viewed as more conservative than the current one.
Politics moves in mysterious ways. President Bush has already signed into law a dramatic expansion of the federal role in education. He has violated free trade principles by signing on to increasing trade tariffs (taxes) for steel and lumber. W is about to put his John Hancock on a monstrous farm bill that reverses the conservative reform farm legislation passed a few years ago. After a period of surpluses, we now have deficits as far as the eye can see.
-----
Will conservatives soon grow nostalgic for the Clinton good old days?
The Bull Moose commits ultimate sin! Calls Clinton a conservative! Says Conservatives may come to miss him! Will soon lose his keys to the VRWC executive washroom!
Bill Clinton, Conservative. The Moose muses that, up until this point, the previous Presidency may be viewed as more conservative than the current one.
Politics moves in mysterious ways. President Bush has already signed into law a dramatic expansion of the federal role in education. He has violated free trade principles by signing on to increasing trade tariffs (taxes) for steel and lumber. W is about to put his John Hancock on a monstrous farm bill that reverses the conservative reform farm legislation passed a few years ago. After a period of surpluses, we now have deficits as far as the eye can see.
-----
Will conservatives soon grow nostalgic for the Clinton good old days?
It is truly horrible when straight people are the victims of anti-gay discrimination.
Fortunately, I'm sure that never happens to actual gay people.
Fortunately, I'm sure that never happens to actual gay people.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
